Tomas Michaud smiling, with his dog Marco Polo on his lap

Get Your Free Weekly Guitar Nuggets

A short, practical guitar tip every Tuesday, from a teacher with 40+ years of helping adults learn.

Plus my short video and checklist: 5 Rules for Cleaner Chords.

Unsubscribe any time.

Which Guitar Is Best for You as a Beginner?

Learning guitar

The best first guitar feels comfortable in your hands, suits the music you want to play, and is set up so the strings don’t fight your fingers. Here’s how I help beginners choose, plus the guitars I recommend right now.

I’ve helped a lot of students choose their first guitar, at my music store and in lessons. In this video I walk through the main types of guitar we start students on, then what makes a guitar ready for a student.

Watch: What’s The Best Guitar For Beginners? Avoid Deadly Mistake #1

Start With the Music You Want to Play

This is the first question I ask. Nylon strings give you the soft, warm sound of classical and Spanish-style guitar, and they’re gentler on your fingertips. Steel strings give you the brighter, louder sound of folk, country, pop and singer-songwriter music.

Choose the type that’s most common in the music you love, because that’s the guitar you’ll want to pick up. For the full comparison, with the same music played on both, see Classical vs. Acoustic Guitar.

If you choose steel strings, expect sore fingertips at first. It usually takes three or four weeks of practice for them to toughen up. If sore fingers would keep you from practicing, start on nylon.

Find a Size That Fits You

A full-size guitar suits most adults. Two smaller options are worth knowing about:

  • A smaller-body steel-string guitar. The same steel strings in a smaller body that’s easier to wrap your arm around. It’s a good choice if a big dreadnought feels bulky against you.
  • A 3/4-size nylon-string guitar. A shorter neck and a smaller body. It’s the guitar we start most children on, and it suits adults with small hands too.

One thing to know about nylon-string guitars: the neck is wider. That gives your fingers more room between the strings, but it’s a longer reach around the neck, which you’ll notice if your hands are small or your fingers are stiff. If you have arthritis, try both types in a store if you can, and notice which one your hands are happier with.

What About an Electric Guitar?

An electric guitar isn’t a bad first choice, especially if you love rock music or want to play with other people. The neck is thin and the strings are light, so they take less pressure to press down. You do need an amplifier, and not only for the volume: without one, you can’t hear well enough to tell whether your fingers are in the right place.

What Makes a Guitar Ready for a Student

Whatever type you choose, here’s what to look for:

  • Low action. The strings sit close enough to the fretboard to press down comfortably, but high enough that they don’t buzz.
  • No buzzing when you play a note correctly.
  • A straight neck, without a bad bow in it.
  • Tuning keys that turn smoothly, without sticking.
  • A sound you like, close to the music you want to play.
  • A size and weight that feel comfortable when you hold it.
  • A look you like. It matters more than people admit, because you’ll want to pick it up.

The action is the one I’d check first. A guitar with the strings set too high is hard to play, whatever it cost. A guitar shop can lower them, and it’s usually worth paying for. Here’s how to make an acoustic guitar easier to play.

Where to Buy

For a first guitar, I’d buy new, from a store with a warranty and people you can go back to if something’s wrong. Ask them to check the action before you take it home.

A used guitar can save money, but a problem like a bowed neck can cost more to fix than the guitar is worth. If you buy used, bring a teacher or a friend who plays.

Not sure yet which type you want? Renting is a good way to try a few before you spend much.

You’ll also want a case. A gig bag (a soft, padded case) protects the guitar and is much lighter to carry than a hard case.

My Current Picks

These are the guitars I’d point a beginner to right now. My music store stocks all four for students, and the FG800 is the one I see most beginners buying.

My current picks (checked November 2026)
Type Model About
Steel-string, full size
For folk, country, pop and singer-songwriter music
Yamaha FG800 $230
Steel-string, smaller body
If a full-size body feels bulky
Yamaha FS800 $230 to $260
Nylon-string, full size
For classical and Spanish-style music, and gentler on the fingers
Yamaha CG122MS $250
Nylon-string, 3/4 size
For children and adults with small hands
Yamaha CGS103AII $170

The three full-size picks have a solid top, which means the top of the guitar is cut from one piece of wood instead of thin layers pressed together like plywood. A solid top usually sounds better, though a lot goes into how a guitar sounds.

Yamaha changes its model numbers from time to time, so if the store has a newer version, ask for the current one. The type and size are what matter. Prices are what US stores were asking in November 2026.

If the Strings Hurt Your Fingers

Some soreness is normal at the start, especially on steel strings. If it’s keeping you from practicing, try lighter strings, or silk and steel strings, which are softer on the fingers. I’m not crazy about their sound, but they’re a good compromise while you’re learning. There’s more in choosing the best guitar strings and stopping finger pain.

Want more lessons like this one? Try Real Guitar Success free for 14 days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    1. Yes, it’s a good bang for your buck at this price range. If you’re a brand new beginner you’ll find the strings hurt your fingers. Check out my blog post on how to make a guitar easier to play.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}