Tomas Michaud smiling, with his dog Marco Polo on his lap

Get Your Free Weekly Guitar Nuggets

A short, practical guitar tip every Tuesday, from a teacher with 40+ years of helping adults learn.

Plus my short video and checklist: 5 Rules for Cleaner Chords.

Unsubscribe any time.

Do I Have to CUT MY NAILS to Play Guitar?

Guitar skills

For years I told my students they had to cut the nails on their fretting hand to play guitar. Then I wondered whether that’s really true, so I tested it with a set of fake nails. Here’s what happened, and what I’d suggest.

This is about the fretting hand only, the hand that presses the strings. The picking hand is a different story. Many fingerstyle players, including flamenco guitarists, grow and shape the nails on their picking hand and use them like small picks.

Watch: Do I Have to Cut My Nails to Play Guitar?

Why Guitarists Keep Fretting-Hand Nails Short

You press most notes with the very tips of your fingers, coming straight down on the string. A long nail hits the fretboard first, so you end up pressing with the pad of your finger instead. Then the finger lies flatter, notes are harder to press cleanly, and it’s easy to touch and mute the string next to it.

Still, I’ve seen players with longer nails who play well, so I wanted to find out for myself.

The Fake Nail Test

I picked up a set of fake nails at the local 99-cent store and put them on my fretting hand.

  • Full length: I couldn’t make a G chord at all. I could press the bass note on the 6th string, and that was it.
  • Trimmed to medium: I could make a G chord, but it was hard. I could play an A chord, almost got a D, and couldn’t get the angle of my first finger right for C.

Medium length on a fake nail is still fairly long for a real one, and it was more difficult than I wanted it to be.

What I’d Suggest

If you’ve worn longer nails for years, you may have learned to work around them in ways I couldn’t in one afternoon. Longer nails don’t rule out playing guitar.

Learning guitar takes practice and patience even with short nails, though. My suggestion is to keep the nails on your fretting hand short, at least while you’re getting started. Once chords feel comfortable, you can let them grow a little and see how long they can be before they get in the way.

If notes still buzz or sound dead with short nails, see how to play chords without touching other strings.

Want more lessons like this one? Try Real Guitar Success free for 14 days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}